I do not totally agree Christian.... details inline...
That said, your summary was easier for me to read than the list...
On 09/27/2012 08:11 AM, Christian Lohmaier wrote:
Where's the difference between "General Discussion" & "Lounge" (or
whatever name will be chosen) - it is not clear to me.
I assume that it is an off "topic forum" where you can ask anything about
anything (well, mostly anyway). Just guessing.
I don't think there is a need for an installation & configuration
category, let alone individual forums for each OS.
Installation is best covered using "Tutorials"/The existing
so I'd remove the Installation category & forums and instead cover it
in Tutorials and in a catchall/general questions section in
libreoffice apps category. After all installing is not black magic...
I partially disagree. One might argue for a specialty forum in general
related to a specific operating system, but I don't think it need be
specific to installation. I also don't think that installation questions
should be handled in tutorials, it is certainly not the first place I would
jump to if I could not install some software.
One nice thing about a separate installation section, is that it will
probably primarily attract the new users that have difficulty in this area.
It will likely not see heavy use, which is probably good because it means
that a new problem will be close to the top where a new person is most
likely to see it and maybe have their question answered immediately.
In LibreOffice Applications, I wouldn't split them out as much, but
rather shrink them to:
* Writer & Math
* Impress & Draw
* Catch-all/General (also the place to ask installation/configuration
problems if not covered by the tutorials) - might even consider to put
Base into this forum as well.
I disagree with this as well, but I will admit that Draw and Impress share
much in common. Math people may be working in Write, and I expect much more
traffic in Write than in Math, but again, categorizing in this way is
generally useful, even if there are only a few posts a month in this
category. The real purpose is that the Math questions are generally very
specific, and it makes it much easier later to browse what has been
discussed in that area. If you can have math be a sub-category of Write,
however, that might be a good thing.
I certainly would not put Base into General, because the questions are so
For installation related questions, people can be asked in a sticky to
prefix their topics with [win] [lin] [mac] (, [sol], [and] [ios],...)
New people in general are not likely to do this. If they are asked as part
of the registration process, however, that might help in this regard.
The SiteFeedback & Website contributor forums seem to overlap
I assume that site feedback is for a general user that wants to say
something like "this forum is horrible because" (or similar). I assume that
the later is for people actively developing the LO web site (ie, not the
And I assume that the Admin-Category will be hidden for Anonymous &
regular Users, right?
One can hope!
So I'd rather start with fewer forums, and if real-life usage proves
me wrong, create the additional, specialized forums.
It is certainly easier to add new categories than it is to remove them.
Math and Draw don't get so many questions that are specifc. Base might
deserve its own section because the nature of the questions is
redically different, and most of the time require database knowledge,
but probably not from a volume perspective. Then again, I don't
read/monitor the english user's list, so it might be different from
e.g. the german project.
So in short:
* remove Installation Category (cover it in tutorial and app-questions)
* combine Apps forums (and create a general forum for non-app specific
question like for installation)
* explain difference between "General Discussion" and "Lounge"
* check overlap betwen "Site Feedback" and "Website"
My Macro Document:
Unsubscribe instructions: E-mail to
Posting guidelines + more: http://wiki.**documentfoundation.org/**
All messages sent to this list will be publicly archived and cannot be