This is a detailed mail, so it shows up as a TLDR; then a
status quo / resolution / benefits triplet, and a link to our FAQ.
We're excited about this as a way to decisively unwind a number of
inter-related problems at TDF. We'll keep an up-to-date version of
this in the FAQ.
Collabora announces that it will move its work on Online from
TDF to GitHub https://collaboraonline.github.io/, in order to ensure
future investment in the software development of Collabora Online and
LibreOffice. This will allow us to deliver on many of the requests
from the community and we expect that this will resolve the lengthy
discussions in the TDF Board around a fair strategy for "LibreOffice
online", thus freeing energy for other constructive topics.
* status quo / resolution / benefits:
** status quo: background & issues
+ the current status of "Online" at TDF is dis-satisfying to
end-users, some community members, Collabora, and it creates
strain in the LibreOffice project.
+ Online has been substantially created, sustained and
continues to be developed by Collabora investment:
+ Collabora's 20+ committers provided 95%+ of the
commits in the last year
+ LibreOffice Online has been a source-only project: a place
to collaborate around development, with own-branded products
versions derived from that. Publicly available products have
encouraged people to buy support when under heavy use.
+ some TDF community, board and staff members have made it
clear they don't accept this compromise, and want TDF to use
the LibreOffice brand to distribute a competing gratis product
in the marketplace driving the price to zero, (perhaps combined
with nags for donations to TDF). Others wish to ship gratis
LibreOffice branded builds not immediately but in 3-6 months.
+ still others dislike the idea of telling users that it is
essential that they contribute to the project, in proportion
to their ability. Others have concerns about even gentle moral
suasion here eg. around tags & naming; others around donation
requests. Still others recommend proprietary software, or sale
of extensions as a solution. Some claim the TDF statues
require one course of action, others that they do not.
+ this combination of uncertain direction, structure and
statutes at TDF make it difficult for an investor today to
have any confidence in a future return over the years in
which that takes when the Online project is hosted by TDF.
+ TDF has historically avoided explaining clearly how
LibreOffice is created even to its own community. It does not
give effective credit to the commercial community members
doing most of the indispensable work in any way
that can drive a proportionate return. There is little
confidence in this improving.
+ The prospect of the Collabora brand having to compete
against something we ~95% build ourselves. ie. with products
sold or distributed gratis under the popular "LibreOffice"
brand - while Collabora continues to sustain, maintain, and
improve the software in an effectively invisible way is deeply
+ imagine trying to explain to larger users why they
should not use LibreOffice Online, but pay for
Collabora Online. Absent significant help from TDF
that is incredibly hard to do in a way that doesn't
damage LibreOffice as a whole.
+ For TDF to provide significant support fairly, in a
way that rewards investment, is incredibly challenging
to achieve inside TDF's structures.
+ There are lots of good people on all sides of this argument
who come from different perspectives. Many of them are
unhappy; we seem stuck in a worst of all worlds position
+ There is an ironic tension here between wanting everything
to be gratis, and wanting investment. Ultimately by making
everything gratis, while not encouraging users to contribute
financially, and having no credible plan to reward investment
- TDF harms its own FOSS mission, which aligns well with
Collabora's: to produce great FLOSS software for everyone.
* TLDR; resolution: a move.
+ To sustain Online and to improve it requires substantial and
ongoing investment and focus, far beyond what TDF can provide
via nags & donations. Any returns require a stable
+ We believe the most elegant way to resolve the strain and
uncertainty is to move our existing sub-project & work around
Online to a new project at Collabora.
+ this accounts for ~1.5% of the size of LibreOffice
core (openhub) and around 1% of the translation
+ This project would have continuity of license and FLOSS
ethos. However it will be hosted outside TDF's
infrastructure and regulation, hopefully as a friendly
daughter project, using its own infrastructure. It would
end up looking much like Fedora, openSUSE, Nextcloud,
ownCloud, Seafile and many others.
+ Clearly TDF committership would transfer to Collabora Online,
and we would welcome and honor all who wish to to contribute.
* TLDR; benefits:
We expect that *iff* this move can be resolved in a
constructive and positive fashion, with a single clear destination
project then we would get these benefits:
+ Collabora will remove the reminder to users to get support
for larger deployments (that annoy some) from CODE as part
of this move.
+ By having a single Online project hosted by Collabora, a
clear brand story easily establishes an appropriate credit for
the origin of the product into every reference to it by those
using it for free. Just like the other prominent OSS projects
we integrate with.
+ This would remove the urgency around some elements of the new
TDF marketing plans, Personal / Community etc. tags, external
entities to offer downloads, difficult algorithms to work out
whom TDF gives priority to in a (hoped for) LibreOffice
Enterprise ecosystem, challenging trademark agreements etc.
+ The 'LibreOffice' brand would have a clearer scope: as both
a Desktop product, and a core Technology which can be built
upon to create amazing things such as Collabora Online.
+ There would be less aggravation in the board and community,
and hopefully a return to positive mutual regard.
+ It would give confidence to Online investors that they
control their destiny; with no-one else to blame.
+ This would allow investment to be sustained to fix bugs, and
to create new FLOSS, meeting TDF's mission. This will continue
to have a positive knock-on impact on improving the
LibreOffice core: filters, rendering, performance, bug-fixes
+ This is an opportunity for TDF to focus its positive energy
on its important mission.
+ This will allow Collabora to experiment with GitHub to see
if it reduces the barrier to contribution, and increases the
pool of available contributors.
+ Collabora hopes the move will aid in maintaining income to
continue investing in LibreOffice: mentoring, contributing
code, sponsoring the conference, funding via the Advisory
Board, mentoring at hack-fests, helping at the ESC, serving
on the board etc.
+ This would also re-balance contribution to LibreOffice core,
making volunteers the largest committers once again, followed
by Collabora, RedHat, CIB, NISZ, TDF etc.
* TLDR; Conclusion
This is primarily a change of presentation, that can un-pick a
big knot of badness in the LibreOffice community. It is primarily
driven by the need for continued investment in Online, in addition to
the huge effort that Collabora and our partners have put into the
product to date.
In our view it is the best solution for both LibreOffice and
Collabora. If the move is handled sensibly we can look forward to a
bright and co-operative future. We start work on that move today; and
encourage people to checkout: https://collaboraonline.github.io/ And
to get involved.
Of course, we would love to see TDF coming up with the right
mix of structure, entities, stability, branding, appreciation of
corporate contributions and so on to build confidence that another
approach is possible. There is time before our next LibreOffice
release in January for the community to ponder what to do with LOOL,
and to do their own thing, or support this move to capture the
benefits outlined above.
Clearly Collabora participants would want to abstain on any board vote
to ship competing Online products, but do expect to be included in the
discussion around that.
* More questions ?
There is an FAQ on-line here:
* Footnote: LibreOffice rocks
In case people got confused, it is worth saying that LibreOffice is an
outstanding piece of software, produced as part of a wonderful, wide
community by some of the best developers, translators, documentors,
etc. you're likely to ever meet. We see LibreOffice as having as
a bright future in two ways:
+ as a great, rich desktop & laptop product (as now)
+ as a core LibreOffice technology - provided via LibreOfficeKit
and UNO APIs - as a re-usable piece of Office awesomeness that can
be built on by other projects and companies like Collabora,
CIB, and many others to build new & valuable products.
We commend it to you, if you’ve not tried before why not:
Of course, Collabora continues to be committed to supporting and
improving our whole product mix, including LibreOffice derived bits,
and contributing back our and our customer's work to the LibreOffice
email@example.com <><, GM Collabora Productivity
Hangout: firstname.lastname@example.org, Skype: mmeeks
(M) +44 7795 666 147 - timezone usually UK / Europe
To unsubscribe e-mail to: email@example.com
Posting guidelines + more: https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Netiquette
List archive: https://listarchives.documentfoundation.org/www/board-discuss/
Impressum (Legal Info)
: Unless otherwise specified, all text and images
on this website are licensed under the
Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 License
This does not include the source code of LibreOffice, which is
licensed under the Mozilla Public License (MPLv2
"LibreOffice" and "The Document Foundation" are
registered trademarks of their corresponding registered owners or are
in actual use as trademarks in one or more countries. Their respective
logos and icons are also subject to international copyright laws. Use
thereof is explained in our trademark policy