Dear members, dear community,
this e-mail is to inform you about the successful resolving of a VAT
audit’s outcome, and a successful recovering of the losses incurred.
We can only now make the details of this settlement public, as the
negotitation phase was confidential for obvious reasons, and stretched
out longer than we had anticipated.
On the details:
In autumn 2017, while talking to the Free Software Foundation Europe
(FSFE), I’ve discovered an issue with the way we handled VAT payments.
TDF as a not for profit is tax-exempt on company income tax, but has to
Next to the nonprofit part, TDF also has a small business part. While
previously, tax authorities put the focus on the nonprofit part,
treating mixed entities as ours like end-users (“B2C”), the regulations
have changed in the meantime, in a way that these have to be handled as
The consequence of this is that cross-border transactions are subject of
“reverse charge”. Our service providers so far had issued invoices with
the respective local VAT, while actually a payment by us to the German
tax office would have been correct.
In other words: While we did pay the VAT, we paid it in the wrong country.
Upon discovering the issue, we acted immediately and also notified the
tax office. It turned out that the situation is not as easy to
understand as it may appear in this summary, with various tax advisors
asked returning different opinions, and some presumed contradicting tax
rules issued in between.
In 2018, the tax office then conducted a VAT audit for the previous
year, resulting in several VAT positions that had to be paid in Germany
by us, instead of being due in foreign countries by the respective
We have always met our requirements in due course, correcting all
previous years back to 2014, paying all the due VAT, interest and late
While in theory, as also assumed by the tax office, a VAT correction is
possible, it turned out that the regulations within the European Union
are very much different and only partially harmonized, if at all.
In other words: The payment obligation with the German tax office was in
force, independent of VAT being paid already, and no matter if a
correction in the foreign countries was possible or not. While in
theory, a “double taxation” is not allowed, that rule here was
unfortunately not applicable.
While some foreign tax offices refunded quickly to the respective
service providers, who paid back to us, others were refusing a refund
for one reason or the other, and others did not react at all.
With TDF being active internationally, with connections to various
countries, the process was a very tedious and time-consuming one,
reviewing lots of invoices, approaching service providers and
interacting with foreign tax offices. Several of us, including Thorsten,
Lothar and myself, spent countless hours over the last three years on this.
Several rounds of objections and discussions followed, until it became
evident that a situation like this is not really foreseen in the system,
and we had to pay VAT (again) on several invoices.
With these damages on the table, negotiations with the tax advise
liability insurance started, to remedy the damages caused.
I’m very happy to report that in autumn 2020, we were compensated for
the damages and other associated costs, totaling to a payment of 90.000
€, with which this case is settled. The alternative, going to court,
spending further months or years, with possible expensive expert
assessments on the various countries, would not have been a good use of
time and money. In the end the TDF incurs almost no damage at all, so it
would not have been worthwile.
I’d like to especially thank our legal counsel, Michael (Mike) Schinagl,
for guiding and advising us on this very complicated topic over the
course of the last three years and on the excellent result he achieved –
without him, this in the end positive outcome would not have been
possible. Thanks truly also to Thorsten and Lothar for their support in
this very time-consuming and energy draining matter. Thanks a lot to
FSFE for helping with identifying this issue, to all the service
providers involved for trying to solve this issue, and last but not
least, thanks to our accountant for their support with the corrections
and the correspondence to the tax office.
I’m more than happy to have this topic finally closed and, in the sense
of cooperating amongst FLOSS communities, while we surely cannot provide
tax advise (you should always consult your own counsel!) and this might
be a special case, I am more than happy to share the knowledge gained on
this with other nonprofit organizations, to help them avoid making the
To unsubscribe e-mail to: firstname.lastname@example.org
Posting guidelines + more: https://wiki.documentfoundation.org/Netiquette
List archive: https://listarchives.documentfoundation.org/www/board-discuss/
- [board-discuss] Information about successful resolving of a VAT audit’s outcome · Florian Effenberger
Impressum (Legal Info)
: Unless otherwise specified, all text and images
on this website are licensed under the
Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 License
This does not include the source code of LibreOffice, which is
licensed under the Mozilla Public License (MPLv2
"LibreOffice" and "The Document Foundation" are
registered trademarks of their corresponding registered owners or are
in actual use as trademarks in one or more countries. Their respective
logos and icons are also subject to international copyright laws. Use
thereof is explained in our trademark policy